Head-to-head
Jane Street vs Volant Trading
A direct, side-by-side comparison of Jane Street and Volant Trading — profit splits, evaluation fees, payout cadence, supported assets, and trading rules. Data pulled live from our firm directory.
Quick verdict
Jane Street is best for
news traders; swing traders holding overnight.
Full Jane Street profile →Quick verdict
Volant Trading is best for
traders who prefer Firm Capital and a New York, NY, USA-based firm.
Full Volant Trading profile →Watch flags · risk only
Public risk notes we've recorded on the firm record. Not a judgement of fit — just things to verify before committing capital.
- Jane Street
regulator warning, pending market manipulation allegations, insider trading lawsuit
Cost & compensation
Cost and compensation path
Published fees and payout timing apply to trader-paid funding programs. Firm-capital and institutional paths are shown separately because their economics usually depend on hiring, allocation, salary, bonus, or profit-sharing terms.
Jane Street
Firm CapitalNot applicable for this model
This is a firm-capital or hiring-based trading path, not a trader-paid funding program. Compensation is typically handled through salary, bonus, draw, allocation, or profit-sharing arrangements rather than a published evaluation fee and payout schedule.
Volant Trading
Firm CapitalNot applicable for this model
This is a firm-capital or hiring-based trading path, not a trader-paid funding program. Compensation is typically handled through salary, bonus, draw, allocation, or profit-sharing arrangements rather than a published evaluation fee and payout schedule.
Trade-offs
Where each firm is weaker
No firm wins on every axis. These are the most meaningful drawbacks of each option — derived from the same structured fields shown in the table, never invented.
Jane Street trade-offs
Open risk note
Watch flag on file: regulator warning, pending market manipulation allegations, insider trading lawsuit
Volant Trading trade-offs
No structural disadvantages versus the other firm based on the fields we track.
Decision guide
Best for your trader type
- Highest profit share
50% vs —%
- News traders
Allows trading through news events.
- Swing & overnight
Permits holding positions overnight.
| Attribute | Jane Street Firm Capital · est. 2000 | Volant Trading Firm Capital |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Evaluation fee | — | — |
| Monthly fee | — | — |
| Evaluation required | No | No |
| Instant funding | No | No |
| Capital | ||
| Profit split | 50% | Salary + bonus |
| Max allocation | Internal capital only — no external trader accounts | — |
| Account sizes | Internal capital only — no external trader accounts | — |
| Scaling | — | — |
| Payouts | ||
| Frequency | Salary + discretionary bonus | — |
| First payout | — | — |
| Assets | ||
| Futures | No | No |
| Stocks | Yes | Yes |
| Options | Yes | Yes |
| Forex | No | No |
| Crypto | Yes | No |
| Trading rules | ||
| News trading | Yes | — |
| Overnight holding | Yes | — |
| Weekend holding | Yes | — |
| Copy trading | No | — |
| Technology | ||
| Platforms | Proprietary internal systems | Proprietary |
| Data feed | — | — |
| Company | ||
| Headquarters | New York, USA | New York, NY, USA |
About Jane Street
Global liquidity provider trading a wide range of products across asset classes.
Full Jane Street profile →About Volant Trading
Options market-making firm active across US equity options exchanges, with a focus on ETF and index options liquidity provision.
Full Volant Trading profile →Trust & stability
Reputation and rule-change activity
Two added decision signals: a weighted reputation score from independent review sources, and a 90-day view of structural rule-change activity where monitored sources are available.
Reputation
Not enough independent rating sources to compute a canonical score yet.
Rule Stability
last 90dWe do not currently have enough monitored public rule sources for this firm to report rule-change activity honestly.
Reputation
Not enough independent rating sources to compute a canonical score yet.
Rule Stability
last 90dWe do not currently have enough monitored public rule sources for this firm to report rule-change activity honestly.
Frequently asked
Common questions
- Which has a higher profit split — Jane Street or Volant Trading?
- Jane Street pays 50% of trader profits once funded.
- Which pays out faster — Jane Street or Volant Trading?
- Jane Street payouts: Salary + discretionary bonus. Volant Trading payouts: not published.
- Can I trade news at Jane Street or Volant Trading?
- Jane Street: permits news trading. Volant Trading: policy unconfirmed.
- Can I hold positions overnight at Jane Street or Volant Trading?
- Jane Street: allows overnight holds. Volant Trading: policy unconfirmed.
Still deciding?
Get a personalized firm match
Answer a few questions about your trading style, account size, and goals. In about 1 minute, we'll rank Jane Street, Volant Trading, and every other firm in our database by fit.
Find my firm match →Disclosure
ProprietaryTrading.com may receive compensation from certain companies featured on this site. These relationships never influence ratings, rankings, match results, verification status, or directory inclusion. Learn more in our Methodology & Editorial Standards.