Head-to-head
Blue Guardian vs Smart Prop Trader
A direct, side-by-side comparison of Blue Guardian and Smart Prop Trader — profit splits, evaluation fees, payout cadence, supported assets, and trading rules. Data pulled live from our firm directory.
Not sure which fits?
Help me decide between Blue Guardian and Smart Prop Trader
Answer 3 quick questions for a lean. The full Match weighs your whole profile.
Cost to first payout
Cost to first payout
What it actually costs to reach payout — a normalized estimate built from each firm's lowest published evaluation cost, monthly fees, and first-payout window. Estimates, not guarantees. Each card shows the assumptions used.
Blue Guardian
Not enough structured fee data published to estimate a cost-to-first-payout figure for this firm.
Smart Prop Trader
estimateApprox. total
$69
to reach first payout eligibility
Approx. time
24days
from sign-up to first eligible request
- Start cost
- $69
- Monthly fee
- —
How we estimated this
- Evaluation path: lowest published one-time evaluation fee.
- Adds ~10 calendar days for evaluation completion (most firms require ≥5 minimum trading days).
- Source — eval fee: $69; monthly: —; first payout: After 14 days.
Trade-offs
Where each firm is weaker
No firm wins on every axis. These are the most meaningful drawbacks of each option — derived from the same structured fields shown in the table, never invented.
Blue Guardian trade-offs
No copy trading
Forbids copy / algo bridges. Smart Prop Trader permits them.
Smart Prop Trader trade-offs
No structural disadvantages versus the other firm based on the fields we track.
Decision guide
Best for your trader type
- Highest profit share
Tie
Both pay 85%.
- Biggest scaling ceiling
Up to $200,000.
- News traders
Allows trading through news events.
- Copy & algo traders
Copy trading is permitted.
| Attribute | Blue Guardian Evaluation-Based Funding · est. 2021 | Smart Prop Trader Evaluation-Based Funding · est. 2022 |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Evaluation fee | — | $69 |
| Monthly fee | — | — |
| Evaluation required | Yes | Yes |
| Instant funding | No | No |
| Capital | ||
| Profit split | 85% | 85% |
| Max allocation | $10K–$200K | $200,000 |
| Account sizes | $10K–$200K | $10K–$200K |
| Scaling | — | — |
| Payouts | ||
| Frequency | Biweekly | Bi-Weekly |
| First payout | — | After 14 days |
| Assets | ||
| Futures | No | No |
| Stocks | No | No |
| Options | No | No |
| Forex | Yes | Yes |
| Crypto | Yes | Yes |
| Trading rules | ||
| News trading | Yes | — |
| Overnight holding | Yes | Yes |
| Weekend holding | Yes | Yes |
| Copy trading | No | Yes |
| Technology | ||
| Platforms | MT4, MT5, Match-Trader | MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 |
| Data feed | — | — |
| Company | ||
| Headquarters | Toronto, Canada | Madrid, Spain |
About Blue Guardian
Canadian evaluation prop firm with rapid, elite and accelerated challenge paths across CFD markets.
Full Blue Guardian profile →About Smart Prop Trader
Spanish forex prop with one-step and two-step evaluation tracks.
Full Smart Prop Trader profile →Trust & stability
Reputation and rule-change activity
Two added decision signals: a weighted reputation score from independent review sources, and a 90-day view of structural rule-change activity where monitored sources are available.
Reputation
canonical- Sources used
- 1
- Confidence
- medium
Weighted blend of independent trader-review sources. See methodology.
Rule Stability
last 90d- Last change
- —
- Type
- —
- Sources monitored
- —
- Status
- No changes detected in monitored sources
Weekly diff of the firm's published rule pages (terms, rules, FAQ, legal). "No changes detected" only means none of the monitored monitored sources changed — other surfaces (Discord, email, dashboards) are not covered. "Limited" or "unavailable" means our monitor cannot reach enough sources to make an honest call.
Reputation
canonical- Sources used
- 1
- Confidence
- medium
Weighted blend of independent trader-review sources. See methodology.
Rule Stability
last 90d- Last change
- —
- Type
- —
- Sources monitored
- —
- Status
- No changes detected in monitored sources
Weekly diff of the firm's published rule pages (terms, rules, FAQ, legal). "No changes detected" only means none of the monitored monitored sources changed — other surfaces (Discord, email, dashboards) are not covered. "Limited" or "unavailable" means our monitor cannot reach enough sources to make an honest call.
Frequently asked
Common questions
- Which has a higher profit split — Blue Guardian or Smart Prop Trader?
- Blue Guardian pays 85%; Smart Prop Trader pays 85% of trader profits once funded. Both firms offer the same profit share.
- Is Blue Guardian cheaper to start than Smart Prop Trader?
- Blue Guardian: evaluation pricing varies. Smart Prop Trader: evaluation from $69.
- Which pays out faster — Blue Guardian or Smart Prop Trader?
- Blue Guardian payouts: Biweekly. Smart Prop Trader payouts: Bi-Weekly. First-payout eligibility: Blue Guardian — n/a; Smart Prop Trader — After 14 days.
- What's the maximum allocation at Blue Guardian vs Smart Prop Trader?
- Blue Guardian scales up to $10K–$200K. Smart Prop Trader scales up to $200,000.
- Can I trade news at Blue Guardian or Smart Prop Trader?
- Blue Guardian: permits news trading. Smart Prop Trader: policy unconfirmed.
- Can I hold positions overnight at Blue Guardian or Smart Prop Trader?
- Blue Guardian: allows overnight holds. Smart Prop Trader: allows overnight holds.
Still deciding?
Get a personalized firm match
A short quiz about your trading style, account size, and goals — we'll rank Blue Guardian, Smart Prop Trader, and every other firm in our database by fit.
Find my firm match →